A Classic Creationist Argument that Science Cannot Dismiss – And Why It Points to a Divine Creator
In an age dominated by the theory of evolution, we, as Orthodox Christians, are often told that science fully supports the idea of life emerging from simple beginnings and growing ever more complex. We are presented with a narrative of an upward climb, from primordial soup to the intricate tapestry of life we see today. Yet, a fundamental pillar of real science—a universal law that governs everything from the stars to the tea cooling in your mug—presents an insurmountable barrier to this naturalistic worldview.
This barrier is the Second Law of Thermodynamics, the Law of Entropy. It's not a theory to be debated, but a foundational law that describes the intrinsic tendency of the universe.
What the Second Law Actually Means: The Universal Drift to Disorder
Simply put, the Second Law of Thermodynamics states that in any closed system, the amount of usable energy decreases over time, and the system naturally moves from a state of order to disorder (or from low entropy to high entropy). This is not just an abstract concept; it is the observable reality of our daily lives and the universe at large. Things fall apart. Structures decay. Order breaks down into chaos. It's why your car rusts, your house needs constant repair, your clothes wear out, and your desk will not spontaneously clean itself. It's why a perfectly constructed building will eventually crumble without constant maintenance. This is not a theory; it is a tried, tested, and universally accepted physical law, perhaps the most robust law in all of science.
The Profound Conflict: Decay vs. Evolutionary Ascent
The core of the evolutionary narrative is a continuous, universal process of increase in complexity:
- Non-living chemicals forming a living cell, with its billions of precisely arranged atoms and molecules.
- Single-celled organisms miraculously evolving into multi-celled life, developing specialized tissues and organs.
- Simple creatures developing increasingly complex organs, intricate brains, sophisticated sensory systems, and ultimately, human consciousness itself.
Evolution posits a grand, unbroken march from chaos to order, from simplicity to incredible, breathtaking complexity. It demands that given enough time and random chance, matter will spontaneously organize itself into ever more elaborate and functional forms.
But how can this claim be reconciled with the Second Law, which unequivocally decrees the exact opposite? How can the universe, which is constantly running down like an unwound clock, be simultaneously building ever-more-perfect biological 'machines' out of random, undirected processes? The Law of Entropy dictates that all natural processes tend toward degeneration, a loss of information and organization. Evolution requires an unexplained, perpetual engine of regeneration, innovation, and ascension that generates new information and complexity. These two concepts are in direct, fundamental opposition.
The 'Open System' Fallacy: Energy is Not Enough
Evolutionists often attempt to sidestep this profound challenge by claiming the Earth is an "open system," not a closed one, because it receives a constant influx of energy from the Sun. They argue that this external energy source can overcome the effects of entropy, allowing for increasing complexity.
However, this is a clever but ultimately insufficient argument, and it fails to grasp the true nature of the problem.
While the Sun provides abundant energy, energy alone does not create specified, complex order. Consider these analogies:
- Pouring gasoline (energy) onto a pile of wood (matter) does not build a house; it simply creates a disorganized, destructive fire.
- Blasting raw energy at a pile of scrap metal will not spontaneously assemble a functional automobile; it will merely create more disorganized debris.
- Heating up amino acids in a test tube does not spontaneously create a living, self-replicating cell with its highly specific informational content and intricate machinery.
To build a complex, specified structure (like a house, a car, or a living organism), you need two things:
1. Energy: The raw power to do work (e.g., the builder's muscle and tools, the Sun's radiation).
2. A Program, Plan, or Blueprint: The pre-existing information content, the intelligently designed instructions that direct the energy to perform work in a non-random way, to create specific order and function.
Evolution provides the energy (the Sun) but is completely lacking the necessary pre-existing program, blueprint, or informational mechanism to direct that energy toward generating the staggeringly complex, highly specified information found in DNA, cellular machinery, and the sophisticated structures of the body. Random mutations, often presented as the source of new information, are overwhelmingly destructive or neutral, and "natural selection" is merely a filter that removes the unfit; it is not a creative, information-generating force. These processes are fundamentally incapable of overcoming the iron fist of entropy to build new, complex biological information and structures from scratch.
The Orthodox Conclusion: A Universe Declaring its Creator
From our Orthodox Christian perspective, the conflict between the Second Law and the theory of evolution only underscores the profound truth of the Creation Account as revealed in Holy Scripture and understood through the Holy Fathers.
The very existence of highly ordered, incredibly complex biological life—organisms that defy the universal tendency toward decay and manifest an astonishing level of specified information—is a powerful and undeniable testament to a pre-existing Intelligent Designer, an ultimate Builder. The complexity of a single cell, with its miniature factories, intricate communication systems, and genetic code, far surpasses any human engineering feat. Such complexity does not arise by chance or undirected energy.
The universe shows clear evidence of a fall from perfection (the very existence of entropy, the curse upon creation). And yet, within that decaying system, we see pockets of profound, specified complexity—life itself. This order is not the result of the system running down; it is the indelible fingerprint of a Creator God who, in the beginning, established perfect order and placed the divine Logos (Word/Plan/Reason) into creation. The psalmist tells us, "The heavens declare the glory of God; and the firmament shows His handiwork." (Psalm 19:1)
The Second Law of Thermodynamics is not just a physics equation; it is a silent, compelling witness against the naturalistic worldview and a powerful argument for the truth of the Divine Creation. We stand on firm scientific ground when we assert that order and specified information always require a Planner, an Architect, a Programmer. The beautiful, intricate, and purposeful order of life cannot have spontaneously emerged or evolved in an undirected manner in a universe defined by the relentless slide into chaos. It points unequivocally to God.
Book Recommendation
(As an Amazon Associate, I may earn a small commission from qualifying purchases.)
Comments
Post a Comment